53 Highlights 34 Differences 8 Reactions 0 Likes

Shure PGA58 vs Shure SM58: 53 Highlights & 34 Differences — So, Which Microphone Actually Works Better

Get insights on sound performance and durability differences in these popular Shure mics. What sets Shure PGA58 and Shure SM58 apart in the music world? We looked at their product type, connection interface, stand/tripod & warranty and key features in this microphones showdown.

57 Points
Shure PGA58
72 Points
Shure SM58
vs

Highlights 159

No extras. Just what matters.
57 Points
vs
72 Points

Why is Shure PGA58 better than Shure SM58 ?

Scroll down for more facts

Shure PGA58 Vs Shure SM58: Dynamic Microphone Face-Off For Vocals and More

Two iconic contenders from Shure, the PGA58 and SM58, share much in common yet serve distinct user needs. Both are dynamic microphones equipped with unidirectional cardioid polar patterns, built to capture vocals and instruments across studios, live stages, podcast booths, and broadcasts. They come housed in sturdy metal chassis with a matte black finish, wired via standard XLR connectors, offering balanced analog audio outputs without relying on phantom power. Both include 5/8" standard mounts compatible with stands and boom arms, protected by a comprehensive 2-year warranty supported by environmental and safety certifications.

Despite these parallels, the PGA58 and SM58 diverge significantly in build robustness, sonic finesse, and accessory features, making each suited for different professional tiers and usage scenarios. The PGA58 shines as a budget-friendly option with a simple on/off switch and fast transient response, while the SM58 boasts superior durability, noise isolation, and advanced mounting versatility tailored for demanding professional environments.

Rising Star: The Shure PGA58's Balanced Blend of Value and Performance

The Shure PGA58 is designed as an accessible, entry-to-intermediate level solution boasting a slightly taller 6.54-inch height with a marginally lighter weight of 0.64 pounds. Its dynamic capsule delivers a frequency response from 50 Hz to 16,000 Hz, extending somewhat higher than the SM58, contributing to crisp, precise sound reproduction with a fast transient response crucial for sharper vocal articulation.

The microphone features a simple on/off switch, setting it apart from typical dynamic mics lacking such control. While it does not include advanced noise isolation or proximity effect handling, its standard preamp quality suffices for casual gigs, podcasting setups, and small studio environments. The package consists of essential accessories such as a carrying case, cables, adapters, and mounting clips, ensuring immediate usability out of the box.

Its moderate size and weight make it comfortable for handheld performance or boom-arm mounting, ideal for users stepping up their vocal or instrument recording game without breaking the bank. The PGA58's simplicity and affordability make it a solid companion for budding musicians, streamers, and content creators seeking dependable Shure quality on a budget.

Classic Performer: Why The Shure SM58 Is Still The Professional's Go-To

The Shure SM58, a legendary classic since its launch in 1966, excels at delivering rugged reliability and refined sonic characteristics demanded by seasoned professionals. Slightly shorter at 6.37 inches and weighing a bit heavier at 0.65 pounds, this mic reportedly withstands rough handling, thanks to its steel grille, internal shock mount, and corrosion resistance, plus drop resistance for the most demanding touring schedules and live shows.

Audio fidelity focuses on voice clarity with its 50 Hz to 15,000 Hz frequency range tuned for natural warmth, paired with an advanced voice isolation system and proximity effect control that eliminates unwanted background noise and handles varying singer distances smoothly. Its transformerless design reduces distortion, and a high max SPL rating of 160 dB allows it to handle loud sound sources without compromising clarity.

Unlike the PGA58's simple switch, the SM58 features a proper gain control, providing manual level adjustment to better suit complex sound environments. Its multiple mounting options, including clip, desktop base, and adjustable swivel/pivot functionality, give it an edge in studio and stage versatility.

The SM58 also integrates RF interference shielding for cleaner transmission in electrically noisy venues, and it's compatible with an optional A58WS windshield, further enhancing outdoor usability. This package includes a stand/tripod, not found in the PGA58 kit, reflecting its professional-grade positioning.

Quick Take

The Shure PGA58 offers an excellent entry point with versatile usage and a handy on/off switch, making it great for beginners and casual performers. Meanwhile, the SM58 stands tall as the tried-and-true workhorse trusted for decades by professionals, featuring rugged construction, precise voice isolation, and comprehensive mounting accessories.

Bottom Line

Choosing between these two Shure microphones ultimately hinges on your needs and budget. If you're starting or need a dependable microphone for light performances, streaming, or podcasting, the PGA58 provides solid sound performance with a simple user experience. For users demanding longevity, superior noise handling, and professional versatility, particularly in live performance or broadcast, the SM58 remains unmatched. Despite its higher price, around $78 at amazon.com for the PGA58 and about $99 for the SM58, the investment in the SM58 pays off in durability and audio quality.

Verdict

  • Winner: Shure SM58 - Its professional-grade durability, superior noise isolation, and enhanced audio control make it the best choice for serious performers and broadcasting professionals.
  • Runner-up: Shure PGA58 - Offers impressive value and user-friendly features ideal for beginners, podcasters, and semi-pro use without sacrificing core Shure quality.

Comparisons 75

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Related comparisons 75

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 159

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

Is Shure PGA58 better than Shure SM58? Depends on your playstyle. This deep microphones breakdown includes specs, feel, tone quality, and what musicians think.

General Information 18

Product Type

What is the product type?

38 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Dynamic

30 Shure SM58 0 Votes Dynamic

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Product Type

Both the Shure PGA58 and SM58 are dynamic microphones designed for professional audio applications, but the PGA58 is part of the PG Alta series released in 2017, whereas the SM58 is from the classic SM Series dating back to 1966, reflecting decades of use and refinement.

Defines the basic category of the microphone.

Model Name

What is the model name?

72 Shure PGA58 0 Votes PGA58

52 Shure SM58 0 Votes SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Model Name

The PGA58 carries the model name 'PGA58', intended as a more budget-friendly alternative, while the SM58 is the iconic SM58 model, renowned worldwide for its durability and performance in live and studio settings.

The specific product identifier from the manufacturer.

Series/Line

What series/line does it belong to?

57 Shure PGA58 0 Votes PG Alta

68 Shure SM58 0 Votes SM Series

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Series/Line

The PGA58 belongs to Shure’s PG Alta series which targets entry to mid-level users, whereas the SM58 is part of the SM Series, designed for professionals wanting a robust, time-tested microphone.

Identifies the product line or collection the microphone belongs to.

Year of Release

What year was it released?

83 Shure PGA58 0 Votes 2017

2 Shure SM58 0 Votes 1966

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Year of Release

Year of release differs significantly: the PGA58 debuted in 2017, a modern interpretation, while the SM58 has been available since 1966, maintaining its legendary status in audio circles.

Indicates when the microphone was launched.

Country of Origin

What is the country of origin?

93 Shure PGA58 0 Votes United States

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes United States

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Country of Origin

Country of origin for both microphones is the United States, ensuring reliable manufacturing standards and consistent product quality.

Manufacturing or design origin.

Intended Use

What is the intended use?

67 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Studio, Live, Podcast, Broadcast, Karaoke

57 Shure SM58 0 Votes Studio, Live, Podcast, Broadcast, Instrument, Streaming

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Intended Use

The intended use for the PGA58 includes studio, live performances, podcasting, broadcast, and karaoke, while the SM58 extends this to include instrument recording and streaming, reflecting its broader professional scope.

Describes the primary application area.

Compatibility

Which devices or platforms are compatible?

55 Shure PGA58 0 Votes PC, Mac, Mixer, Audio Interface, PA System

58 Shure SM58 0 Votes PC, Mac, iOS, Android, Mixer, Camera

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Compatibility

PGA58 is compatible with PC, Mac, mixers, audio interfaces, and PA systems, while the SM58 adds iOS, Android, and cameras to its compatibility list, making it versatile for various recording platforms.

Lists supported platforms and devices.

Form Factor

What is the form factor?

48 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Handheld

40 Shure SM58 0 Votes Handheld

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Form Factor

Both models feature a handheld form factor, suiting vocal performances and easy mobility on stage or in studio environments.

Describes the physical style of the microphone.

Polar Pattern Type

What is the polar pattern type?

68 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Cardioid

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Cardioid

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Polar Pattern Type

Cardioid polar pattern remains consistent between the two, focusing on direct sound sources while minimizing background noise for clear audio capture.

Identifies the default pickup pattern.

Connectivity Type

What is the connectivity type?

38 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Wired, XLR

10 Shure SM58 0 Votes Wired

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Connectivity Type

Connectivity is wired for both with XLR connection type, assuring professional-grade, noise-resistant audio transmission.

Defines how the microphone connects to devices.

Color Options

What are the color options?

68 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Black

70 Shure SM58 0 Votes Black

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Color Options

Color options for both are classic black, professional and unobtrusive for stage or studio use.

Available product colors.

Mounting Type

What is the mounting type?

53 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Stand, Boom Arm

38 Shure SM58 0 Votes Stand, Boom Arm, Clip, Desktop Base

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Mounting Type

Mounting options for the PGA58 include stand and boom arm, whereas the SM58 also supports clip and desktop base mounting, offering more versatile setup choices.

The typical mounting or support style.

Dimensions & Weight 14

Height

What is the height?

6.54 inch 1 Votes
Shure PGA58
6.37 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Height

Height differs modestly: PGA58 stands 6.54 inches, taller by 0.17 inches (4.3 mm) compared to SM58’s 6.37 inches, impacting handheld comfort minimally.

The microphone’s overall height.

The height difference between these mics is noticeable but minor the PGA58 is a bit taller which might affect handling slightly.

See more

Weight

What is the weight?

0.64 lbs 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0.65 lbs 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Weight

Weight is nearly identical: PGA58 weighs 0.64 lbs, just 0.01 lbs lighter than SM58’s 0.65 lbs (about 5 grams), making both similarly portable.

The microphone’s physical weight.

Width

What is the width?

2.17 inch 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Width

The PGA58 measures 2.17 inches in width, slightly wider than the SM58 at 2 inches, making the PGA58 marginally bulkier by 0.17 inches (4.3 mm).

The microphone’s overall width.

Depth

What is the depth?

2.17 inch 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Depth

Depth is equal at approximately 2.17 inches for PGA58 versus 2 inches on SM58, making the PGA58 a bit deeper.

The microphone’s overall depth.

Cable Length

What is the cable length?

14.8 ft 0 Votes
Shure PGA58

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Cable Length

The PGA58 comes with an approximately 14.8 ft (4.5 m) cable, whereas the SM58’s cable length isn’t specified, which might require purchasing separately, giving PGA58 an advantage in package included accessories.

Length of the included or integrated cable.

Mounting Thread Size

What is the mounting thread size?

98 Shure PGA58 0 Votes 5/8"

70 Shure SM58 0 Votes 5/8"

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Standard 5/8" thread size fits most microphone stands, making it easy to mount.

The thread size for mounting compatibility.

Package Width

What is the package width?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

5.5 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s width.

Package Depth

What is the package depth?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2.5 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s depth.

Package Height

What is the package height?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

9 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The shipping package’s height.

Stand/Arm Length

What is the stand/arm length?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Maximum length of included stand or boom arm.

Capsule Diameter

What is the capsule diameter?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Capsule Diameter

Capsule diameter is unspecified for PGA58, while SM58’s capsule diameter is 2 inches (50.8 mm), indicating the SM58 may house a larger capsule for sound capture.

The diameter of the microphone capsule.

Capsule Length

What is the capsule length?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

2.3 inch 0 Votes
Shure SM58

The length of the microphone capsule.

Audio Performance 29

Voice Isolation Feature

Does it have voice isolation?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 1 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Voice Isolation Feature

The SM58 features voice isolation, whereas the PGA58 does not, giving the SM58 an edge in reducing unwanted ambient sound pickup.

Whether the mic includes isolation tech.

The SM58 includes voice isolation which helps reduce background noise making it better for live or noisy settings.

See more

Frequency Response (Max)

What is the maximum frequency response?

16,000 Hz 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
15,000 Hz 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Frequency Response (Max)

Both mics have similar frequency response lows at 50 Hz, but the PGA58 extends up to 16,000 Hz versus SM58’s 15,000 Hz, offering a slightly wider high-frequency range potentially enhancing clarity.

The highest frequency the mic can capture.

Transient Response

What is the transient response?

98 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Fast

40 Shure SM58 0 Votes Medium

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Transient Response

Transient response is rated fast for PGA58 and medium for SM58; the PGA58 might capture rapid sound changes more accurately improving detail capture.

Ability to capture sudden sound changes.

Sensitivity

What is the sensitivity?

-55 dBV/Pa 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
-56 dBV/Pa 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Sensitivity

Sensitivity varies slightly: PGA58 sensitivity is -55 dBV/Pa and SM58 is -56 dBV/Pa, with a 1 dB difference favoring PGA58’s slightly higher sensitivity, possibly capturing quieter sounds more effectively.

Output level relative to sound pressure.

Proximity Effect Control

Does it have proximity effect control?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Proximity Effect Control

Proximity effect control is available on SM58 which enhances bass response when close to the mic, while the PGA58 lacks this feature, impacting vocal warmth control.

Whether it has control for bass buildup at close range.

Internal Preamp Quality

What is the internal preamp quality?

47 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Standard

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Internal Preamp Quality

Internal preamp quality is standard for PGA58, unspecified for SM58, but the legendary performance of the SM58 suggests a robust internal design.

Describes the built-in preamp’s fidelity.

Frequency Response (Min)

What is the minimum frequency response?

50 Hz 1 Votes
Shure PGA58
50 Hz 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Covers a wide frequency range for vocals, starting from as low as 50 Hz, ensuring a deep, full sound.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 has a frequency response range starting at 50 Hz, which helps capture the low-end frequencies of most vocal and instrument sounds.

The lowest frequency the mic can capture.

Both mics start their frequency response at 50 Hz but the PGA58 extends higher which can contribute to a brighter sound.

See more

Directionality

What is the directionality?

38 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Unidirectional

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Unidirectional

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Directionality

Both microphones are unidirectional, ideal for isolating vocals and minimizing ambient noise.

General pickup orientation.

Output Impedance

What is the output impedance?

150 ohm 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
150 ohm 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Output Impedance

Output impedance is identical at 150 ohms, ensuring compatibility with most professional audio equipment without impedance mismatch issues.

Electrical resistance of the microphone’s output.

Acoustic Principle

What is the acoustic principle?

68 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Pressure Gradient

60 Shure SM58 0 Votes Pressure Gradient

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Acoustic Principle

Acoustic principle used by both is pressure gradient, common in dynamic microphones for effective sound pressure handling.

The underlying sound capture mechanism.

Microphone Type

What is the microphone type?

68 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Dynamic

50 Shure SM58 0 Votes Dynamic

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Dynamic microphones like this one are ideal for high-output sound sources, providing durability and reliability.

Defines the operating principle of the microphone.

Max SPL

What is the maximum SPL?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

160 dB 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Max SPL

Maximum SPL is 160 dB for SM58, while PGA58 does not specify max SPL, but performance likely comparable for high sound pressure tolerance.

The maximum loudness before distortion.

Connectivity & Interfaces 15

Ground Lift Switch

Does it have a ground lift switch?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Ground Lift Switch

Neither microphone has a ground lift switch, meaning they rely on external equipment for ground loop noise resolution.

Prevents ground loop hum in audio systems.

Connection Interface

What is the connection interface?

38 Shure PGA58 0 Votes XLR

20 Shure SM58 0 Votes XLR

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Connection Interface

Both use XLR connection interface, the industry standard for professional audio, ensuring reliable wired connection.

Defines the main interface for connectivity.

Cable Detachable

Is the cable detachable?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Cable Detachable

Cable is detachable in both microphones, allowing easy replacement or customization.

Whether the cable can be detached or replaced.

Audio Output Options

What are the audio output options?

48 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Analog

88 Shure SM58 0 Votes Analog, Balanced

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Audio Output Options

Audio output options in PGA58 are analog only, while SM58 offers balanced analog output, reducing noise over long cable runs.

Lists output signal formats available.

Phantom Power Support

Does it support phantom power?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Phantom Power Support

Neither microphone supports phantom power, consistent with dynamic microphone operation.

Whether the mic supports phantom power.

Multi-Device Pairing

Does it support multi-device pairing?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

This microphone is a single-device unit, ensuring clear and dedicated audio output.

Ability to connect to multiple devices simultaneously.

Balanced/Unbalanced Output

What is the output type?

38 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Balanced

85 Shure SM58 0 Votes Balanced

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Balanced/Unbalanced Output

Balanced output is offered on both, aiding noise rejection in professional setups.

Defines the type of electrical signal output.

Dual Output Capability

Does it have dual output capability?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The PGA58 is designed for single-output use, providing simplicity and focus for vocal performances.

Ability to provide two simultaneous outputs.

XLR Pin Configuration

What is the XLR pin configuration?

97 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Standard

90 Shure SM58 0 Votes Standard

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The standard XLR pin configuration ensures compatibility with most professional audio equipment.

Specifies XLR wiring configuration.

Shielding Against RF Interference

Is there RF shielding?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Shielding Against RF Interference

Shielding against RF interference is included in the SM58 but not in the PGA58, giving SM58 better resistance in challenging RF environments.

Indicates built-in protection against RF interference.

Wireless Technology

What wireless technology is used?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The wireless system type used.

Bluetooth Version

What Bluetooth version does it support?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Version of Bluetooth supported (if applicable).

Power & Battery 12

Auto Power-Off

Does it have auto power-off?

No 1 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

This mic does not feature an automatic power-off function, offering simple, manual control.

Whether the microphone shuts down automatically when idle.

Neither mic has an auto power-off feature so you have to remember to turn them off manually to save power.

See more

Power Source

What is the power source?

8 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Passive

90 Shure SM58 0 Votes Passive

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Power Source

Both are passive microphones requiring no external power source, simplifying use without batteries or phantom power.

Defines how the microphone is powered.

Replaceable Battery Support

Does it support replaceable batteries?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

There is no battery support for the PGA58, relying on external devices for power.

Indicates if batteries can be swapped.

External Power Supply Compatibility

Is it compatible with an external power supply?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The PGA58 does not require or support external power supplies, simplifying setup.

Can the mic run on external AC/DC supply.

Power Indicator Light

Does it have a power indicator light?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

It lacks a power indicator, keeping the design minimal and straightforward.

Whether a light shows power/battery status.

Phantom Power Requirement

What is the phantom power requirement?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Specifies the phantom power voltage needed.

Battery Type

What is the battery type?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The type of battery used if portable.

Battery Capacity

What is the battery capacity?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Storage capacity of the built-in battery.

Battery Life

What is the battery life?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

How long the microphone operates per charge.

Recharge Time

What is the recharge time?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Time required to fully recharge the battery.

Power Consumption

What is the power consumption?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Amount of power drawn during use.

Charging Method

What is the charging method?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The interface used for recharging.

Controls & Features 18

Headphone Monitoring

Does it support headphone monitoring?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Headphone Monitoring

Neither microphone supports headphone monitoring, so external monitoring is necessary.

Direct monitoring via headphone output.

Monitoring Mix Control

Does it have monitoring mix control?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The mic does not offer direct mix control, but can be used with external mixers for full control.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 does not have a built-in monitoring mix control.

Lets user adjust mic vs playback audio mix.

On/Off Switch

Does it include an on/off switch?

Yes 1 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

This feature adds convenience, allowing quick control over microphone use during live performances.

Whether the microphone includes a physical on/off switch.

The PGA58 has an on off switch which is super handy for quick muting unlike the SM58 which lacks this feature.

See more

Gain Control

Does it have gain control?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 1 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Gain Control

Gain control is present on the SM58 but not on the PGA58, allowing more direct sound level adjustment on the SM58.

Ability to adjust input gain directly.

Gain control is present in the SM58 giving more control over sound levels while the PGA58 does not have this.

See more

Onboard Controls

What onboard controls are available?

62 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Switches

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The onboard switch gives users control over the mic’s operation, perfect for turning it on or off during use.

Types of direct physical controls.

Touch/Motion Controls

Does it support touch/motion controls?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

This microphone does not feature touch or motion controls, ensuring a simple interface.

Allows interaction via touch gestures or motion.

LED Indicator Lights

Does it have LED indicators?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The PGA58 does not include LED indicator lights, keeping the focus on performance without distractions.

Lights that show status such as mute, levels, or power.

App/Software Integration

Is it integrated with software/apps?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

No app or software integration, providing a straightforward, plug-and-play experience.

Works with companion apps or software.

EQ Presets

Does it have EQ presets?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Lacks built-in EQ presets, relying on external devices for sound adjustments.

Pre-configured equalization modes.

Voice Effects

Does it include voice effects?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The PGA58 does not include voice effects, ensuring the natural clarity of the vocal performance.

Built-in voice modulation effects.

Feedback Suppression

Does it have feedback suppression?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Without dedicated feedback suppression, care should be taken when positioning to avoid feedback.

Prevents audio feedback loops in live use.

Automatic Gain Adjustment

Does it support automatic gain adjustment?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

There is no automatic gain adjustment, so users will need to adjust levels manually on the connected device.

Auto-adjusts mic gain for consistent output.

Build & Design 18

Drop Resistance

Is it drop resistant?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 1 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

The PGA58 is not designed for drop resistance, so careful handling is recommended.

Indicates if the mic is designed to survive accidental drops.

The SM58 is built for more rugged usage as it has drop resistance which is great for touring and live shows.

See more

Shock Mount

Is a shock mount included?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Shock Mount

The SM58 includes an internal shock mount providing enhanced resilience to handling noise; PGA58 lacks this, possibly making it more sensitive to handling sounds.

Whether a shock mount is included to reduce vibrations.

Pop Filter

Is a pop filter included?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Pop Filter

SM58 integrates a pop filter to reduce plosive sounds, which the PGA58 does not, potentially requiring an external filter for clean vocal recordings.

Whether a pop filter is provided for plosive reduction.

Water Resistance

Is it water resistant?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

This mic is not water-resistant, so it should be kept dry to avoid potential damage.

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The Shure SM58 is exceptionally rugged, though not officially waterproof. Its durable construction and use of heat- and water-resistant adhesives enable it to withstand water submersion and even exposure to saltwater, although its performance may be temporarily affected under such conditions.

Indicates if the mic is resistant to water.

Body Material

What is the body material?

78 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Metal

88 Shure SM58 0 Votes Metal

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Body Material

Metal body construction is common to both, providing durability for stage and studio use.

The main structural material of the microphone body.

Finish/Coating

What finish/coating does it have?

68 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Matte

85 Shure SM58 0 Votes Matte

Shure PGA58
vs
Shure SM58
Finish/Coating

Both mics have a matte finish for a professional, non-reflective look.

Exterior treatment or surface finish.

Dust Resistance

Is it dust resistant?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58

Dust resistance is not a feature, so users should avoid exposing the mic to excessive dust or dirt.

Indicates if the mic is resistant to dust.

Grill Material

What is the grill material?

58 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Metal

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes Steel

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 features a durable steel mesh grille that protects the microphone capsule from physical damage.

The material of the protective mic grill.

Internal Dampening Material

What is the internal dampening material?

78 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Foam

78 Shure SM58 0 Votes Foam

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

Foam is used inside the microphone to reduce handling noise and vibrations.

The material used internally to reduce noise/vibration.

Windscreen

Is a windscreen included?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a windscreen is included for wind noise control.

Adjustable Arm/Stand

Does it have an adjustable arm/stand?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether the arm/stand can be adjusted.

Detachable Mount

Is the mount detachable?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

If the mount can be detached for flexibility.

Package & Accessories 13

Stand/Tripod

Is a stand/tripod included?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a stand or tripod is included in the box.

Spare Parts Availability

Are spare parts available?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

Spare parts for the SM58 are readily available through Shure and authorized retailers.

Whether the manufacturer provides replacement parts.

Mounting Clip

Is a mounting clip included?

Yes 1 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a clip for attaching to stands/instruments is included.

Both come with a mounting clip so you can easily attach them to mic stands but SM58 offers more mounting options overall.

See more

Cables

Are cables included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if connecting cables are provided.

Carrying Case

Is there a carrying case included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a protective carrying case is part of the package.

Adapters

Are adapters included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

States if adapter(s) are included (e.g., XLR to 3.5mm).

Extra Windscreen

Is an extra windscreen included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if a spare windscreen is included.

Instruction Manual

Is an instruction manual included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a manual or quick-start guide is included.

Packaging Type

What is the packaging type?

18 Shure PGA58 0 Votes Box

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes Box

Defines how the product is packaged.

Stickers/Branding

Are stickers/branding included?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if stickers or branded items are in the package.

Warranty Card

Is a warranty card included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Whether a warranty card is included.

Protective Foam Insert

Is protective foam included?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if protective foam is part of packaging.

Certification & Compliance 7

Warranty

What is the warranty period?

2 years 0 Votes
Shure PGA58
2 years 0 Votes
Shure SM58

Duration of manufacturer warranty coverage.

FCC/CE Approval

Is it FCC/CE approved?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Shure SM58
Shure SM58

The SM58 is certified with FCC and CE approvals, ensuring compliance with international safety and regulatory standards.

Explicit FCC/CE compliance approval.

Safety Compliance

Is it safety compliant?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates adherence to safety regulations.

Environmental Compliance

Is it environmentally compliant?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Compliance with eco/environmental regulations.

RoHS Compliance

Is it RoHS compliant?

Yes 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Restriction of Hazardous Substances directive compliance.

Professional Broadcast Certification

Is it broadcast certified?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

Yes 0 Votes Shure SM58

Indicates if the mic meets pro broadcast standards.

Temperature Range (Operating)

What is the operating temperature range?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

80 Shure SM58 0 Votes 0° to 122°F

Operating temperature window for reliable use.

Advanced Features 15

Multi-Pattern Switching

Does it support multi-pattern switching?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to switch between multiple pickup patterns.

DSP Processing

Does it include DSP processing?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Built-in digital signal processing for sound shaping.

AI Noise Cancellation

Does it feature AI noise cancellation?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

AI-powered suppression of background noise.

Beamforming Technology

Does it support beamforming?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Uses mic arrays to focus on sound sources.

Voice Tracking

Does it include voice tracking?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Automatically follows speaker’s voice.

Recording Profiles

Does it have recording profiles?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Predefined sound settings for specific uses.

Surround Capture Mode

Does it support surround capture?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to capture immersive 360° or surround sound.

Auto Calibration

Does it support auto calibration?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Automatically adjusts mic response to environment.

Low Latency Monitoring

Does it support low-latency monitoring?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Provides near real-time monitoring with minimal delay.

Smart Assistant Compatibility

Is it compatible with smart assistants?

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure PGA58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Shure SM58 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Integration with voice assistants.

Cloud Profile Storage

Does it support cloud profile storage?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Saves mic settings to the cloud.

Firmware Upgrade Support

Does it support firmware upgrades?

No 0 Votes Shure PGA58

No 0 Votes Shure SM58

Ability to update functionality via firmware.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Sound Quality

How would you rate the sound quality of this microphone?

Crisp and professional
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good and clear
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Average clarity
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Distorted and unclear
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Noise Handling

How well does this microphone handle background noise?

Blocks out most noise
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Handles noise fairly well
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Reduces some noise
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Picks up everything
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Battery Life

How long does the battery last on this microphone?

Excellent — Over 20 hours
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Long lasting — 10 to 20 hours
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent — 5 to 10 hours
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Short — 2 to 5 hours
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very short — Under 2 hours
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Durability

How durable is this microphone based on build and lifespan?

Highly durable — Over 4 years
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Solid — 2 to 4 years
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Average — 1 to 2 years
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very fragile — Less than 1 year
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Weight

How heavy is this microphone?

Ultra-light — Under 150 grams
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Lightweight — 150 to 300 grams
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Medium — 300 to 500 grams
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Heavy — 500 to 800 grams
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very heavy — Over 800 grams
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Design Appeal

How attractive is the design of this microphone?

Plain and boring
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Somewhat okay
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Nice looking
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Stylish and modern
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Pricing

How do you feel about the price of this microphone?

Great value for money
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Pretty good price
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Fair deal
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Kinda pricey
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Crazy expensive
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Sensitivity

How sensitive is this microphone to capturing sound?

Very sensitive — Detects quiet sounds clearly
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Sensitive — Captures a wide sound range
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Moderate — Picks up normal voice levels well
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Low — Needs to be close to sound source
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Very low — Struggles to capture soft voices
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Frequency Response Range

What do you think about the frequency response range of this microphone?

Wide range — 20 Hz to 20 kHz
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good range — 30 Hz to 18 kHz
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent range — 40 Hz to 16 kHz
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Limited range — 50 Hz to 14 kHz
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Narrow range — Above 60 Hz only
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Connectivity

How stable and reliable is the connection of this microphone?

Excellent — Always stable, no dropouts
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Good — Works smoothly with rare issues
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Decent — Occasional minor disconnections
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Weak — Disconnects sometimes
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58
Poor — Frequently loses connection
0 Votes
Shure PGA58
0 Votes
Shure SM58

Guides 2

Files 1

Shure PGA58 Manual PDF

zzounds.com
zzounds.com

Articles 1

Shure SM58 Manual

Shure SM58 Manual

shure.com
shure.com

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Shure
Shure
Shure PGA58
Shure PGA58
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Shure
Shure
Shure SM58
Shure SM58
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 4

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More Microphones 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Shure Microphones 76

Other Shure Microphones 71

Shure PGA58
Shure
Shure
Shure PGA58
Shure SM58
Shure
Shure
Shure SM58
vs